DNA Workplace

Guide for UK employers

Reasonable Suspicion Drug Testing: A Manager's Checklist

By DNA Workplace · Published 16 November 2026 · 5 min read

A blue safety helmet and hi-vis jacket

Reasonable suspicion drug testing is what a manager does when they believe someone may be unfit for work through drugs or alcohol and need to act. It might be a colleague who arrives unsteady, slurring their words or behaving out of character. You can't be sure what's behind it, but what you do next matters: for their safety, for the people around them and for how fairly you treat them.

This guide, and the free checklist that goes with it, is for that moment: what to look for, how to rule out other explanations, how to handle the conversation and what to write down.

What reasonable suspicion testing is

Reasonable suspicion testing, often called for-cause testing, happens when a manager has specific, observed grounds to believe someone may be unfit for work through drugs or alcohol. It's different from random testing, where selection has nothing to do with behaviour.

The ICO says you're more likely to be able to justify testing after an incident where there's a reasonable suspicion of drug or alcohol use than random testing. The catch is that the suspicion has to rest on what you've seen and heard, not on gossip, reputation or a hunch. Your policy should say who can request a test, on what grounds and what happens next. Our guide to writing a workplace drug and alcohol policy shows how.

Signs that may point to impairment

HSE Northern Ireland's guide for employers, Drug misuse at work, lists signs that may suggest drug misuse, including sudden mood changes, unusual irritability or aggression, confusion, swings in concentration and energy, poorer work, poor timekeeping and more short-term sickness absence.

On the day, you're more likely to notice something specific:

  • Behaviour: aggression, mood swings, confusion or drowsiness that isn't like them

  • Speech: slurred, slow or rambling

  • Coordination: unsteady on their feet, poor balance, fumbling with tools or controls

  • Performance: uncharacteristic mistakes, near misses, or trouble following simple instructions

  • Other signs: a smell of alcohol or cannabis, or alcohol or drugs in their possession at work

One sign on its own rarely tells you much. A clear change from someone's normal, several signs together, or any sign alongside a safety risk is what should prompt you to act.

Rule out other explanations

Signs like these can have other causes, such as stress, so treat them as indications, not proof. Plenty of things can look like impairment:

  • low blood sugar, which the NHS says can make someone feel confused and blur their vision

  • extreme tiredness, after night shifts or long hours

  • side effects of prescribed or over-the-counter medicines

  • a head injury or another medical emergency

  • stress, anxiety or bereavement

If someone seems seriously unwell, treat it as a medical situation first: get a first aider and call 999 if needed.

Make it safe first

Before you talk about testing, remove the risk. Take the person off safety-critical work straight away, as a precaution rather than a punishment. Don't let them drive, and that includes driving home. If you can, ask HR or another manager to join you.

How to approach the conversation

Speak to them privately and promptly, ideally with a second person present.

  • Describe what you've seen, not what you think it means. "You were unsteady on the ladder and I can smell alcohol" is fair; "You're drunk" isn't.

  • Ask how they are and whether anything could explain it, such as feeling unwell or a new medication.

  • Listen. A credible medical explanation may mean the next step is first aid, a referral to occupational health or a lift home, not a test.

  • If your concern remains, explain that your policy allows a test, what it involves and what happens if they refuse.

  • Stay calm, keep it confidential and don't involve their colleagues.

When to ask for a test

Ask for a test when, after the conversation, you still have reasonable grounds to believe the person may be unfit for work through drugs or alcohol, and your policy allows it. Test as soon as you can, because the longer you wait, the less the result can tell you about the time you were concerned.

If they decline, don't push. Record what they said and follow your policy.

Use a trained collector, follow chain of custody and get any non-negative screen confirmed in a laboratory. Remember that a confirmed result shows a substance was present, not how impaired someone was. Your notes from the time are what show how the person was affected at work, so the record matters as much as the test. If your team works in safety-critical roles, see our guide to drug and alcohol testing in safety-critical industries.

Write it down and be consistent

Record what happened while it's fresh, with times: what you saw and heard, who else saw it, what the person said, which other explanations you considered, what you decided and why. Keep to facts, not conclusions.

Apply the same standard to everyone, whatever their seniority and however well you know them. HSE Northern Ireland's guide says that training managers and supervisors to recognise the signs "could be the most crucial part of managing drug misuse at work".

Keep it confidential and know who to call

Share the details only with people who need them, usually HR, occupational health and whoever makes the decision. Your policy should name who managers escalate to, including out of hours, and how they arrange a collector.

Whatever the outcome, the aim is the same: to get the person, and everyone around them, home safely. If there's a drug or alcohol problem behind it, the HSE treats dependence as a medical condition that deserves the same support as any other.

Download the checklist

Our free reasonable suspicion checklist takes managers through each step on a single form, from making the situation safe to signing off the decision. Download the checklist (PDF, 2 pages) and keep copies wherever managers might need one.

Need help with for-cause testing, or with training your managers? Contact DNA Workplace.

Frequently asked questions

What is reasonable suspicion drug testing?

Reasonable suspicion testing, often called for-cause testing, happens when a manager has specific, observed grounds to believe someone may be unfit for work through drugs or alcohol. It differs from random testing, where selection has nothing to do with behaviour.

Is reasonable suspicion testing easier to justify than random testing?

The ICO says you're more likely to be able to justify testing after an incident where there's a reasonable suspicion of drug or alcohol use than random testing. The suspicion must rest on what you've seen and heard, not on gossip, reputation or a hunch.

What should a manager do first if they suspect someone is impaired?

Make it safe. Take the person off safety-critical work, make sure they don't drive, including home, and check whether they need first aid or medical help. If they seem seriously unwell, treat it as a medical emergency and call 999 if needed. Then speak to them privately, ideally with a second person present.

What should a manager write down?

Record what happened while it's fresh, with times: what you saw and heard, who else saw it, what the person said, which other explanations you considered, and what you decided and why. Keep to facts, not conclusions.

This guide is general information for UK employers and is not legal advice. Laws and official guidance change, so take advice on your own circumstances before relying on it. Where a guide relies on an official source, the source is linked in the text.

DNA Workplace Limited · Company No. 11036947 · Unit G1, Frome Business Park, Manor Road, Marston Trading Estate, Frome BA11 4FN

0203 943 8371